Is There Anybody Out There?
Finding the human at the limits of AI


We are living through an unprecedented moment in history: the moment when tasks are starting to be divided according to one criterion. On one side are those that deserve to be done by humans. On the other are those where we can do without the human element and let artificial intelligence take over. (I’m talking here about everyday, user-level use of AI.)
There are tasks for which not using this tool might seem almost absurd. Why not let AI help us sort out our finances in a spreadsheet? Why not let it help us rephrase things and fix grammar mistakes when we need to file a complaint? Reality shows, however, that AI isn’t only used for tedious, repetitive tasks; we often turn to it for advice, comfort or entertainment. Teenagers play games against machines every day, and surveys show that in some countries more than 70% of people have used AI to support their mental health.
And I wonder: if we had time to spare, would it seem so obvious to use this tool for activities that are, dare I say… so human? But we're so eager to get more done, to squeeze every drop out of the time we have, to be able to do everything and be everywhere at once, that we lose ourselves in that drive. AI ends up taking on the most repetitive tasks (hallelujah for that), but also some deeply human ones. That wears away our ability to reach out to one another, until needing someone else starts to feel optional. This tendency to do without the human element isn't limited to our private lives; it's happening in organisations too: read the FAQs, talk to the bot, fill in the form… so that it's getting harder and harder to feel there's anyone on the other side. It's a paradox that the internet, created to connect us, so often ends up connecting us to a kind of "digital void".
Technology may still be a long way from real care: giving a hug, cooking a pot of lentils, wiping a bum, or offering you a bed for the night. But we are moving towards a place where services are increasingly mediated by hybrid experiences, where you don’t know whether you’re talking to a human. And sometimes it’s almost a relief to be talking to a machine, so that no flesh-and-blood person has to weather the storm you’re bringing.
But if there’s one thing we can learn from this, it’s that there’s something about talking about your own stuff, even if it’s just with a machine, that brings relief. And there’s something that brings even more relief: talking about your own stuff knowing there’s a human on the other side. For me, that’s undeniable. And there’s something that brings more relief still: knowing that the person on the other side isn’t doing it under any kind of structural pressure, but because they genuinely enjoy listening to what you’re going through, because somehow it touches the same things that move them, or prompts them to ask questions of their own.
What started out simply as a result of the informality with which we began this project (we had no message templates, no FAQs, no one managing social media, nothing of the sort) has gradually become something that sets us apart from the prevailing way of doing things. I see more and more value in the openness to begin every new contact with a “How about we have a call this week and talk?” That’s how almost every conversation starts with anyone who’s interested in what we offer, and I’d say it’s After the Rains’ way of being in the world. This week, I’ll make space to call you, to listen to you, to hear who you are and what brings you to us, and I’ll give you my personal number so you can reach me if anything comes up. And do you know what? Not once have I felt that anyone abused that trust.
Notice how something that a while ago I must admit felt a bit like flying by the seat of our pants has gradually become a hallmark of the project. Attending to people with space, knowing a call can run on with no time limit imposed from outside, because this isn’t about rates or efficiency but about caring for people humanly from the very first moment. And it doesn’t only happen with the participants in our retreats and services; it happens between us too. Oliver and I spend hours on the phone and send each other hundreds of voice notes about ideas going round in our heads, things we want to refine, impressions left from the last retreat. To-dos get mixed up with doubts, with reflection, and with the mutual support I feel we also give each other. Absolute chaos, if you look at it with a critical eye for how an efficient project’s workflows ought to run. But all that disorder has value because it’s alive, and because we’re always immersed in a process of creating with another human. I’m grateful to be able to keep running a project with so much informality and closeness.
To me, AI is a wonderful excuse to ask ourselves questions that lead us to rethink what we need from others today, what we expect from the world, and above all which activities are still worth doing (and which aren’t).


